View Count: 1761
Throughout our commercial career we require to attend several meetings. Most of these are a complete waste of time as they are unfocused and more often result in no action taking place.
In this publication authored by Sean McPheat, the Founder and Managing Director of management development specialists at MTD Training, explains how to run effective meetings. A fitting read for Project Managers, the publication informs readers on how to run an effective meeting by looking at several different topics like, why should a meeting be held, preparing the meeting agenda, strategies to bring in effectiveness in the meeting, improving communication skills to reach set goals and ways to follow-up on tasks.
Running Effective Meetings
|1.1||Overview of the Ebook|
|1.2||Why Are You Holding a Meeting?|
|1.3||Scheduling the Meeting|
|1.4||The Meeting Agenda|
|1.5||Before the Meeting|
|1.6||General Operations During the Meeting|
|1.7||Basic Communication Skills for Meetings|
|1.8||Working Effectively in Meetings|
|1.9||After the Meeting|
|2||Why Are You Holding a Meeting?|
|2.2||The Meeting’s Objective|
|2.3||Is a Meeting Necessary?|
|2.4||Who Should Come to the Meeting?|
|3||Scheduling the Meeting|
|3.2||Common Problems When Scheduling a Meeting|
|3.3||Tips for Scheduling a Meeting|
|4||The Meeting Agenda|
|4.2||The Agenda Format|
|4.3||How to Use the Agenda|
|5||Before the Meeting|
|6||General Operations During the Meeting|
|6.2||Laying the Ground Rules|
|6.3||Running the Meeting|
|7||Basic Communication Skills for Meetings|
|7.2||Verbal vs. Non-verbal Communication|
|8||Working Effectively in a Meeting|
|8.2||Problem Solving Skills|
|8.6||Managing Conflict in a Meeting|
|9||After the Meeting|
|9.3||Prepare and Send Meeting Summary|
|9.4||Follow Up on Tasks|
Throughout your commercial career you will attend a lot of meetings!
Some meetings are more productive than others and it all comes down to the way that the meeting is set up and run.
We’ve all attended meetings that have been a complete waste of time where everyone “talks a good game” but no action actually comes from it!
In this textbook we’ll cover the main key considerations, skills and approaches to make sure that the meetings that you run are focused, outcome orientated and focused on getting action.
Sean McPheat, the Founder and Managing Director of management development specialists, MTD Training is the author of this publication. Sean has been featured on CNN, BBC, ITV, on numerous radio stations and has contributed to many newspapers. He’s been featured in over 250 different publications as a thought leader within the management development and training industry.
MTD has been working with a wide variety of clients (both large and small) in the UK and internationally for several years.
MTD specialise in providing:
MTD provide a wide range of management training courses and programmes that enable new and experienced managers to maximise their potential by gaining or refining their management and leadership skills.
Our team of highly skilled and experienced trainers and consultants have all had distinguished careers in senior management roles and bring with them a wealth of practical experience to each course. At MTD Training we will design and deliver a solution that suits your specific needs addressing the issues and requirements from your training brief that best fits your culture, learning style and ways of working.
Our programmes are delivered when and where you need them! We believe that training should be fun, highly interactive and provide “real world” practical techniques and methods that you can use back in the office – and that’s exactly what we provide.
1.1 Overview of the Ebook
We have all been to meetings that, when we left, we knew had been a waste of time. In fact, we can feel as if we spend the majority of our day in meetings. However, few meetings are run as effectively as they could be. In this ebook, you’ll learn how to run an effective meeting by looking at several different topics:
1.2 Why Are You Holding a Meeting?
Many meetings we attend are unnecessary. In this chapter we’ll look at when it is appropriate to hold a meeting, as well as when it is not. We’ll also talk about the importance of clarifying your meeting’s objectives. Otherwise, why should anyone come if you don’t even know what it is you want them to meet for?
1.3 Scheduling the Meeting
So, you want to meet on Thursday at 4:00 p.m. for 30 minutes. But the next thing you know, people can’t come, they want to have the meeting last longer or shorter, or they would rather you hold the meeting at a different location. Yes, it can be frustrating to schedule a meeting with multiple people who all have their own schedules and their own priorities. But in this chapter we’ll look at some tips that can help you do so.
1.4 The Meeting Agenda
What do you think of when you think of a meeting agenda? A piece of paper with a list of a few topics on it, right? Well, we’re going to look at the meeting agenda as a tool that can help you to be much more effective in a meeting – and can help everyone else to do the same as well. How many times have you expected someone to be prepared for a meeting but they show up and haven’t done any of the preparation necessary? Or have you ever had someone show up, look at the agenda, and determine that really the person who should be there from their department is Steve, who is on vacation for the next week.
In this chapter, you will learn that the meeting agenda is the key to running an effective meeting. When you use it appropriately and to its fullest potential, it is a means of gaining agreement regarding the meeting objectives, a way to prepare the participants for what is expected of them during the meeting, and a tool that will help you keep the meeting on track.
1.5 Before the Meeting
Once you’ve sent out the agenda, there are just a few things left that you need to handle before the meeting. In this chapter we’ll take a look at these items and share some information that will help you make sure that the meeting runs smoothly. There are also some things you should consider about the location that you choose and the set-up of the meeting room itself.
1.6 General Operations During the Meeting
Now that you’ve planned for and prepared for the meeting, it’s time to get into the meeting itself. But how do you run an effective meeting? What do you need to do or not do? We’ll talk about strategies for effectiveness in this chapter. The first step is to agree with the group on what the ground rules will be for the meeting. For example, you might agree to take two breaks, one after the first hour and one after the second hour. Or you might agree as a group that you will raise your hand and wait to be acknowledged before speaking. Ground rules are particularly important when your meeting will cover controversial subjects or when you expect there to be some level of conflict between the meeting attendants. We’ll also talk about some additional ways to manage the meeting so that you stick to the agenda and achieve your objectives.
1.7 Basic Communication Skills for Meetings
What is a meeting but an organized form of communication? You need to be able to listen to others, digest information, and communicate back to the other people in the meeting. We’ll briefly look at some basic communication skills that will help you to communicate effectively during your meeting.
1.8 Working Effectively in Meetings
In this chapter, we’ll look at some skills that will be useful in the middle of a meeting such as how to brainstorm effectively, problem solving skills, persuasion skills, and more. The goal of this chapter is to help you lead the group through the meeting agenda and towards the accomplishment of the meeting objectives.
1.9 After the Meeting
Your job isn’t over just because the meeting is. In order to make sure that the time you and all the other participants spent in the meeting wasn’t wasted, there are some steps you need to take after the meeting. You’ll want to get feedback on how the meeting went, send out the meeting summary or minutes, and follow-up on the tasks that were assigned during the meeting.
2) Why Are You Holding a Meeting?
Meetings, meetings, and more meetings. It can seem like we spend the majority of our professional lives in meetings. But many of these meetings are not necessary, are not productive, and endup being a waste of time. Not just of your time, but the time of everyone that comes to the meeting. If travel is involved, catering was ordered, or any other expenses incurred, the meeting can be a very expensive production. In this chapter we’ll discuss how to determine whether or not a meeting is truly necessary.
2.2 The Meeting’s Objective
Before you can determine whether or not you truly need to hold a meeting, you need to determine what the objective of your meeting would be. Why do you need to meet? If you don’t know what you are trying to achieve, then you will be wasting time if you do meet. Meetings can have more than one objective. To help you determine what they might be, ask yourself the following or similar questions:
If you don’t know what you are trying to achieve with your
meeting, then any meeting you have will be a waste of time.
Your meeting objectives are the measuring stick you will use when the meeting has been held to determine whether or not your meeting has been productive. If you leave the meeting and you have achieved your objectives, the meeting was successful. So, complete the following sentence:
At the end of the meeting, I want the group to….
When you fill in the rest of that sentence, you should know what your main objective is. Here is an example of a poor objective:
To discuss the upcoming fundraiser.
This is not a good objective because there is no specific outcome. You could discuss the fundraiser for hours, but what is the true outcome that you want after the discussion is over? Some possibilities of true meeting objectives for this meeting might include one or all of the following:
You should be able to use the objective to help you determine whether or not a meeting is absolutely necessary as well as who you need to invite to the meetings.
2.3. Is a Meeting Necessary?
Many meetings that we hold or attend are not actually necessary. However, knowing the objective doesn’t mean that you have to have a meeting to achieve it. Ask yourself why you think a meeting is the best means to achieving your objective. Often you could achieve the same objective by picking up the telephone for a few minutes or by sending out a couple of emails. The times that you need to hold a meeting are more limited than you might think.
Often we could achieve the same objective just by picking up the
telephone for a few minutes or by sending out a couple of emails.
Some good reasons to hold a meeting are:
One word of caution about using email as a means to achieving your objective: too often, people have long, drawn-out discussions via email. While this can be effective in some decision-making, it can also leave a great deal of room for misunderstanding or miscommunication.
In face-to-face communication, over 90% of what we are communicating is non-verbal: our body language, tone of voice, and speed of speech. In email communication you are relying on only the verbal portion of communication. So don’t allow email communication to go on for too long or to occur at all if the topic is highly technical or very important.
2.4 Who Should Come to the Meeting?
When you have decided that a meeting is the best choice for achieving your objective, the next decision you need to make is whether or not everyone you first think to invite to the meeting actually needs to come to the meeting.
Think about this for a moment:
10 people in a meeting x average salary of $30 an hour = $300 per hour
So if this group of 10 people has a two-hour meeting, the cost to the organization for the meeting is $600. Not to mention the loss of whatever work the people could have completed had they not been in the meeting. So before you invite someone to the meeting, ask yourself if they really need to be there. Ask yourself the following questions:
If you can achieve your objective without this person, why are you considering inviting them to the meeting? Sure, there are times that the politics of your organization mean that a particular person should be invited. For example, perhaps this is a meeting where all the other department directors are coming, so to leave the final department director out might be unwise. But most of the time, you should limit the meeting’s attendees to those people who are absolutely necessary.
3) Scheduling the Meeting
When you have decided that a meeting is necessary, now you need to schedule the meeting. If you are the supervisor of the entire group that needs to come to the meeting, then this might be easy for you most of the time. But in many cases it is a challenge to schedule a meeting with the busy schedules that we all have.
3.2 Common Problems When Scheduling a Meeting
We’ve all had the experience of trying to schedule a meeting that seems more like an attempt to solve a brain teaser than to get a few people together. Here are some common problems that occur when attempting to schedule a meeting:
Many of these probably rang true for you. Whatever the reason for having a problem with scheduling a meeting, the results are the same:
3.3 Tips for Scheduling a Meeting
One way that can be effective when scheduling a meeting is to use an internal scheduling software – as long as it is a requirement that everyone use the software. If you only have a few people using it, the software can end up causing more problems than resolving them. However, there are some other things you can do to help you be effective when scheduling a meeting. Some suggestions include:
If you are launching a new project that will require regular meetings, don’t worry about scheduling all of them before you’ve met the first time unless you have some urgent reason to do so. Instead, wait until you’ve held the first meeting to make sure that the people you’ve invited are actually the right people to participate on the team. Then you can decide as a group when the next meeting(s) will be.
4) The Meeting Agenda
It is not an understatement to say that your agenda and the way you use it can be the key to whether or not your meeting is successful. The agenda is not just a list of what is going to happen or what you are going to discuss at the meeting. It is also:
4.2 The Agenda Format
The exact appearance of your agenda is not as important as making sure that it includes all of the following information:
You can also choose to include a list of the people who will be attending and their titles, particularly if the group doesn’t know each other or if there will be people attending from outside the organization. An example of a possible agenda format is shown in Figure 1.
Figure 1: Sample Agenda Format
Each section of the agenda provides information that will inform the attendee, make sure that they are prepared, and help you control the meeting once it starts. Let’s review each section that we haven’t talked about yet.
And each one may have multiple corresponding objectives.
Time Allocated – Here you give the amount of time to be allocated to each topic. Be sure that the total amount of minutes that you indicated on your agenda does not exceed the overall duration of the meeting that you have indicated at the top of the agenda. This information will be helpful to you as you progress through the meeting because you can use it to manage the conversation. We’ll talk more about using the agenda during the meeting in later chapters.
Topic Leader -just because you are organizing the meeting, that doesn’t mean that you will be leading the discussion on every topic. In this column you should indicate who will be the discussion leader. This could be the person who has the most information on the topic, the person who raised a concern that got the topic placed on the agenda, or the main decision-maker over the area that the topic concerns. This is also an indication to the person that they should be prepared to act as the discussion leader during the meeting.
Objective – as we’ve discussed, this is where the objective or objectives should go. Don’t be afraid to list several objectives under each topic. You want everyone to know what you expect to achieve at the meeting so that they are prepared to do so.
4.3 How to Use the Agenda
Once you have completed the agenda, you should send it out to your meeting participants for comments, changes, or additions. You may hear back that they have something important that they also need to discuss at the meeting, and you want to know that ahead of time rather than waiting until the meeting and having them bring it up when there is no time allocated for it on the meeting schedule. Give the group of people a deadline for responding to the agenda if they have any changes.
Once you’ve received their changes (or lack thereof), you can make any necessary changes and send the agenda and the associated attachments back out. At this point, you should consider the group of people as having committed to the agenda as-is. Then before and when you get into the meeting, the agenda will serve several purposes. It will:
You have basically used the agenda as a means of getting agreement from the group of participants as to what will happen during the meeting and what will be decided. That should make it much easier for you to keep everyone on task and moving effectively through the discussion.
5) Before the Meeting
There are certain tangible aspects of effective meetings that should be considered if your group is to be as productive as possible and if you want to have the best attendance as possible. In this chapter we will look at a few areas of consideration that will help you ensure that your meetings are set up appropriately and that you’ve thought of details that will help foster a productive meeting environment.
5.2 Meeting Location
When you consider the meeting location that you want to use, there are a few aspects to consider. These are:
First, you should consider what location would be the most convenient for your participants. If you have multiple meetings for this project, look for a variety of locations so that you vary the distance that people have to travel each time. Also consider parking. Is there plenty of free, close parking or will the participants have to fight for metered spaces? You want to communicate any specific parking information to the participants when you send out the agenda so that people allow sufficient time for parking and walking to the meeting site.
When you consider the comfort of various locations, consider several aspects:
Finally, have you considered how suitable the location will be? For example, if you are having a meeting to discuss sensitive information, can you be sure that the location you’ve chosen will allow for privacy? If you are going to need to do an audio visual presentation, is there equipment available for your use there, or will you have to bring everything with you? Here are some other questions to consider:
5.3 Seating Arrangement
When you have decided that the location is comfortable, convenient, and suitable, now you need to consider the seating arrangement. For example, will you be assigning seats by putting tent cards out at the spaces, or will you be allowing people to sit wherever they choose? When you think about the purpose of your meeting, there might be some advantage to having certain people sit next to each other.
Next you should think about the arrangement of the tables and chairs in the room. If your meeting is more of an instructional session or if you are just disseminating information, you might choose to set the tables and chairs up in rows. But if you are going to have a discussion or brainstorming session, the best arrangement would be to set the chairs and tables up in a ‘U’ shape so that everyone can easily see and listen to each other.
5.4 Meeting Preparation
The day before the meeting, send out a reminder email to all of the attendees. Next, mentally walk through the meeting to determine what you need to bring with you. Decide whether or not you will bring copies of any supporting information, such as the things you asked them to read, to the meeting. If so, make the copies the day before as well so that you avoid any last-minute problems. If you are bringing other items to the meeting, pack a box the day before so that you are prepared. For example, do you need white board markers? Name tags? It’s never a bad idea to bring pens and pads of paper to the meeting as well, if you have them.
6) General Operations During the Meeting
In this chapter we will look at several techniques to help you operate during the meeting. You may not need to apply all of these to your meeting. It depends on the type of meeting you are having, the level of conflict you expect, and how well the group you have coming knows each other. However, these tips are designed to help you have more effective meetings by using your time well and helping you achieve the goals you set for the meeting.
6.2 Laying the Ground Rules
In some meetings, when you have a good group that works and brainstorms well together, you don’t have to worry about ground rules. Particularly if you will be meeting for multiple times, the first meeting is a good time to focus on how you would all like the meetings to operate so that you get the most done in the shortest amount of time and without anyone getting too upset. Some possible ground rules are things like we will:
You can make a list of these ground rules ahead of time that you propose to the group at the first meeting, or you can allow the group to come up with their own rules. Either way, you want to make sure that you have agreement on the ground rules before moving forward.
6.3 Running the Meeting
During the meeting, your job as the meeting organizer is to move the group through the agenda. Make sure everyone has a copy of the agenda when the meeting starts, and progress through the topics in the order they are listed on the agenda. Someone needs to be assigned to take notes during the meeting if you are not able to. If something comes up that is not on the agenda, assure the group that you (or the assigned person) will capture that topic or item for later discussion. However, if the item that came up somehow impacts your ability to complete the rest of the agenda, consider handling it then – but explain to the group why you are allowing this deviation from the agenda.
If discussion is continuing on a topic and you are about to come to the end of the time you have allocated for the item, ask the group to do one of several things:
Here are some additional tips for helping the meeting to be as effective as possible:
This chapter has looked at the general way that a meeting should operate to provide you with the most effectiveness. In the next chapters we will look at how to communicate with others during the meeting as well as ways to deal with conflict that might arise.
7) Basic Communication Skills for Meetings
When you are in a meeting, you need to be able to communicate well with others in order to come to get your ideas across, understand the ideas of others, and come to decisions as a group. In this chapter we will look at some basic communication skills that will be helpful to you in meetings – as well as any other interactions you have with other people.
What does it take to communicate with another person? How are we communicating even when we aren’t using words? When you begin studying communication, you’ll find that we communicate with much more than our words. In face-to-face communication, our words are only part of the message. The balance of the message, and in fact, the largest part of the message that we are sending to others is made up of non-verbal information. It is composed of our body language and our tone of voice. Figure 2 below demonstrates this fact.
Figure 2: Face to Face Communication
7.2 Verbal vs. Non-verbal Communication
Remember that communication skills involve both verbal and non-verbal communication. Albert Mehrabian’s work on verbal and non-verbal communication in the 1960’s and early 1970’s is still considered a valid model today. He posed that the non-verbal aspects of communication such as tone of voice and non-verbal gestures communicate a great deal more than the words that are spoken. He also found that people are more likely to believe your non-verbal communication than your verbal communication if the two are contradictory. In other words, you are most believable and most effectively communicating when all three elements of face-to-face communication are aligned with each other.
We instinctively recognize what body language and other
non-verbal forms of communication are telling us.
7.2.1 Tone of Voice
According to Mehrabian, the tone of voice we use is responsible for about 35-40 percent of the message we are sending. Tone involves the volume you use, the level and type of emotion that you communicate and the emphasis that you place on the words that you choose. To see how this works, try saying the sentences in Figure 3 with the emphasis each time on the word in bold.
The same sentence can have multiple meaning
depending on which word is emphasized. The emphasis on a
particular word implies additional information than what the words say.
Figure 3– Impact of Tone of Voice
Notice that the meaning of the sentence changes each time, even though the words are the same. The emphasis you place on the word draws the listener’s attention, indicating that the word is important somehow. In this case, the emphasis indicates that the word is an error. So in the first example, I didn’t say he borrowed my book, the phrase includes the message that someone else said it. The implied information continues to change in each sentence, despite the words remaining the same each time.
7.2.2 Body Language
Over half of the message we are sending can be due to body language. Body language is a subconscious way that we communicate, but it is one that we recognize in others on instinct. Examples of body language include:
Basically, body language includes anything they are doing with their body besides speaking. We recognize this communication instinctively, without having to be told what it means. It is important that when you speak to the other person, your body language supports rather than contrasts what you are saying. This is particularly true when you need to build trust with the other person because any contrast between your words and your body language could be construed as deception.
7.3 Listening Skills
Being effective in a meeting requires that you can listen to and understand what the other person is telling you. It sounds simple enough, but the truth is that good listeners are rare these days. Studies have shown that most listeners retain less than 50% of what they hear. Imagine what that means when it comes to a conversation that you might have with your boss, a colleague, or a customer. If you speak for ten minutes, chances are that you have only heard about half of that conversation – and so have they. No wonder miscommunications happen so frequently!
Studies have shown that most listeners retain less than 50% of what they hear.
In order to be a good listener, you should practice active listening skills. There are five key aspects of becoming an active listener. You are probably already employing some of them, but may need to practice others. However, once you are using these tools over time, you will find that they get easier and easier. Plus, you’ll learn so much about your customers, colleagues, and co-workers, and you’ll have such better conversations with them, that you will be positively reinforced each time you practice.
7.4 Interpersonal Skills
Interpersonal skills are more than just communication skills. They are the ‘people skills’ that seem to come to some of us so naturally, while other of us may struggle with them. Interpersonal skills will help you to work with others and build rapport with them, but they will also help you to respond to hold meetings in a productive manner.
Some interpersonal skills include:
8) Working Effectively in a Meeting
In the last chapter, we looked at some general communication skills that are needed to express your ideas and understand the ideas of others, as well as some skills that would help you communicate more effectively in general. The skills discussed in this chapter are more focused communication skills that will help you to solve problems or resolve conflicts in a meeting. Conflicts and problem solving can stall a meeting’s progress, so knowing how to move past them is essential if you want to run an effective meeting.
8.2 Problem Solving Skills
Many meetings are held to come to a consensus on how to solve a problem. The tricky part of this situation is ensuring that the problem that you are attempting to solve is the actual problem that exists.
For example, a co-worker might come to you saying that they need you train their employees on how to use their software correctly. You could just write the training and deliver it and move on. Or instead, you could meet with the co-worker and others in positions of authority and ask questions in order to determine what the problem is that they are trying to solve with the training. You may then be able to:
One simple problem-solving tool is to use something called ‘The Five Whys.’ It is simple because it uses the question ‘why’ up to five times in order to help get to the root of a problem. But remember that it is indeed a simple tool – if you are dealing with a more complex problem, you may need to learn other problem-solving skills. An example of how to use this tool is shown in Figure 4 below. Notice that in this case, it’s not necessary to use five ‘why’ questions to get to the root of the problem.
|I need a copy of your ABC billing
|Might I ask why?|
|We are having problems keeping track
of customer bills.
|Why are you having trouble?|
|We do it by hand, but now our
customer base has grown so much
that we can’t keep up. Correspondence
in general is difficult.
|Why is correspondence difficult?|
|Because we have about 10 different
pieces of information that have to go
out to different customers in addition to
the bills. Keeping all that in order is
quite a challenge.
|It sounds to me like you need more
than a billing system – it sounds like a
customer contact management
system is what you really need. Why
don’t I show you some of the benefits
it could provide?
Figure 4: Using the Five Whys Tool
8.3 Persuasion Skills
You may find that in some meetings, you need to persuade others. You may need to persuade them to accept a decision, to make a decision, to move on to the next point on the agenda, or any number of other things. The most important skill in persuasion is the ability to understand the point of view of the other person and then provide information on your position that will matter to that person. The facts might be important, but the benefits of those facts, or the impact of those facts, are what will persuade the other person to your side.
As an example, let’s look at persuasion skills that are important for selling. In fact, all persuasion is a form of selling – whether it’s selling a product or an idea. Let’s imagine that you sell alarm clocks – a simple example, certainly, but it will help you to see the difference between features and benefits in Figure 5 below.
|Dual Alarms||Lets you set a back-up to be sure that
you don’t oversleep, or lets you set
different alarm times for different
|Large, Illuminated LED Numbers||Makes it easy to see the time without
turning on any lights. Easy to see
even if you are sleeping without
glasses or contacts.
|AM/FM Radio||Allows you to enjoy music at any time,
or to set your alarm to activate on the
music station of your choice.
|MP3 Player Jack||Turns your alarm clock into speakers
for your MP3 player for use at any
time of day. You can also program the
clock so that you wake up to your
favorite songs on your MP3 player.
|Durable Plastic Casing||This clock can withstand those early
morning slaps to turn the clock off.
|One Year Manufacturer’s Warranty||Protects your investment. With any
malfunction of the clock, you can get a replacement in the first year.
Figure 5: Comparison of Features and Benefits
Now imagine that you are meeting with your boss and trying to persuade her to allow adjusted time schedules (flexible scheduling) and working from home one day per week. What would the features and benefits be? See Figure 6 for an example.
|Employees can work from home one day
|Better employee satisfaction and retention.
Improved work output on one day of
telecommuting. Fewer traffic-related
tardies and fewer traffic-related absences
due to accidents. Reduced overall
employee stress levels.
|Employees can work flexible schedules,
working their eight hours anytime
between 7am and 7pm as long as it is
scheduled ahead of time.
|Better employee satisfaction and retention.
Less tardiness and fewer absences related
to childcare issues. Improved customer
service because someone will usually be
available across all twelve hours to
respond to customer.
Figure 6: Features and Benefits of Flexible Time Schedules and Telecommuting
Of all the tools that you will use in meetings, brainstorming is the least complicated and the easiest to use anytime, anywhere. When people are engaged in a brainstorming discussion, the ideas should be flowing out and everyone should be participating. To help your brainstorming sessions be as productive as possible, consider the following guidelines
8.5 Fishbone Diagrams
Fishbone diagrams are visual representations of the information that you gather during a brainstorming, problem-solving, or troubleshooting discussion or exercise. It is a way to organize your thoughts into like groups and establish relationships between those thoughts. While fishbone diagrams are excellent for exploring issues or finding the causes of a problem, they are not useful for identifying timelines or costs associated with the solution. The fishbone diagram gets its name from the fact that the way it is drawn often resembles the skeleton of a fish. It was designed by a Japanese industrial quality management professor named Kaoru Ishikawa, so they are sometimes referred to as Ishikawa diagrams as well.
A fishbone diagram usually has two ‘sections’ to the drawing. On the left hand side (and the majority) of the diagram, you list the suspected causes of a situation, problem, or issue. On the right hand side, you have the ‘head’ of the fish, which is the effect, the situation, or the issue itself. Each ‘rib’ of the fish leads into the ‘ spine’ of the fish and indicates a factor that you believe is contributing to the overall problem or situation. These diagrams are usually hand-drawn during a brainstorming discussion, but an example of a fishbone diagram is shown in Figure 7 below.
Figure 7: Example of a Fishbone Diagram
Each of the ‘ribs’ of the fish may have sub-issues, which could also then have sub-issues. You can continue to ‘branch’ each rib down to several levels of issues if you need to. The end result is that you have a kind of ‘map’ of the situation, with all of the factors that are causing the problem or situation that you can think of. You can now prioritize each factor depending on how much influence you believe it has on the result. As you investigate and eliminate factors from consideration, you will identify the main source of a problem or issue.
Common factors that are placed on a fishbone diagram are:
Of course, some of these might actually be sub-factors of each other. For example, under people, you could have management or training. It simply depends on the situation you are examining and the factors that are affecting it.
8.6 Managing Conflict in a Meeting
Conflicts will happen from time to time. It will be helpful to you in managing conflict in a meeting if you have a bit of information about the conflict styles that people might use. Then we’ll look at a specific way to help resolve conflicts when you’re in the middle of one.
8.6.1 Preferred Conflict Styles
The theory that people have one of five preferred conflict styles was posited by Kenneth Thomas and Ralph Kilmann in the 1970s. Similar to the way that communication styles can help you to identify how another person is communicating their concerns to you, these five styles will help you to understand why the other person might be acting the way they are during a conflict. You can also choose a given conflict style to apply during meeting discussions, depending on the situation that you are dealing with. They are:
Competitive: These people like to win. They like to be in a position of power and will definitely take notice of who has the most authority in a conflict situation. They may decide to dig in on a position, even if they don’t yet have all the facts. This is a useful style when you have to get into action and make a decision (when you don’t have time for a lot of discussion), when you know the decision you want to put in place is going to be unpopular, or when you have someone else you are dealing with who is being aggressive or trying to exploit a situation. Be warned, however, that this style often results in hurt feelings and dissatisfaction in others, so it should be reserved for emergency or occasional situations.
Collaborative: This is the opposite style of competitive. In this style, you try to accommodate everyone’s point of view. You might be assertive, but you want everyone’s input because you believe it is important. When you have existing conflict in a group that has not been resolved, when the decision needs buy-in from everyone, or when the situation is very important, you can use this style.
Compromising: In this style, you go into the discussion expecting that every person involved will need to make compromises of some sort, including you. The attempt is made to find some aspects of the solution that will satisfy everyone in the party. This is a useful style when it is more important to have agreement and consensus on an issue than to hold on to your point of view. Or, you can use it when you have two equally strong opponents who seem to be deadlocked at this point of their discussion. This can be a time-intensive strategy as well, so it might not be the best choice if you have a tight deadline.
Accommodating: In this situation, you don’t give a lot of opposition to the other party. You are willing to make concessions in order to make the other person happy or give them what they want. You are cooperative rather than assertive. In general, you use this style when the relationship with the other person is more important than getting a specific outcome, or when you really don’t have a great deal of stake in the discussion or the results.
Avoiding: When you use this style, you actually seek to avoid the conflict entirely. You might try to delegate it to another party or to avoid making a decision that you know might be unpopular. If it is appropriate to pass the conflict on to another party who has more information or is more invested in the outcome, then by all means, do so. However, this is more often than not going to be a bad choice in strategy. There are few situations in which avoiding conflict will actually be beneficial.
8.6.2 The Interest-Based Relational Approach
The interest-based relational approach, called IBR for short, lets you respect the differences among individuals involved in the conflict but also helps to keep them from becoming too attached to a specific position. To use this strategy, you follow a simple set of rules when you go over ground rules of the meeting. They are:
9) After the Meeting
Just because the meeting was adjourned, that doesn’t mean that your attempts to have the meeting be as effective as possible are over. There are several steps you should take after every meeting to make certain that the time you invested was not wasted.
9.2 Get Feedback
All of us can improve on our meeting skills. If you look at every meeting you organize as a learning opportunity, then you will quickly figure out what you need to do to improve your skills by asking yourself what went well and what could have gone better – but by asking the others in the meeting for feedback as well. You can get this feedback in one of several ways:
The type of questions that you ask the other participants will vary depending on the type of meeting you had, but some of the questions you should be asking yourself and others for any type of meeting include:
9.3 Prepare and Send Meeting Summary
In an ideal world, you could assume that everyone in the meeting was paying attention, taking notes, and understood what they needed to do once they left the meeting. However, we don’t live in a perfect world. It’s more likely that at least one person was on their smart phone the whole time, another one zoned out for part of the conversation, and another one just plain didn’t care about what was going on. So it’s up to you as the meeting coordinator to make sure that the important information shared during the meeting -including what tasks were assigned to each person – is captured and sent out to the group.
You may have a standard meeting minutes format, or you may need to create one. In either case, use your meeting agenda as a guide and be sure that you capture the following on your document:
You may also want to capture any information that led to the specific decision or assignment. For example, perhaps during the meeting you discovered that Joe Smith will be on vacation for the next two weeks. Therefore, all the IT tasks that would normally be assigned to Joe will be given to Sue.
Why is it important to be thorough with a meeting summary? Because you don’t know exactly who else might be reading it. For example, participants might send the meeting summary on to their supervisors or to other team members who need to know some of the information. If you don’t provide enough context in the meeting summary, you may have people end up poorly informed. Another reason to be thorough is because you can use your meeting summaries as a record of what decisions were made and why. If anyone ever questions why you made a certain decision, you can go back to your meeting summary to find the answer. Finally, one last reason to be thorough is so that anyone who missed the meeting can be caught up by reading the summary. That way you won’t have to worry that someone is acting without full information.
Timing is important when you send out the meeting summary. You want to try to get it done within a couple days. Don’t wait weeks and weeks to send out the summary, because people will forget certain details. Plus, if they had tasks to complete, you want to remind them of that so that they can put time on their schedules to complete the tasks.
9.4 Follow Up on Tasks
If you are the meeting coordinator because you are also the project manager or the person responsible for the topic at hand, then you will want to establish a way to follow-up on tasks that were assigned to others. It may be helpful for you to create a spreadsheet that allows you to sort tasks by the person assigned, by the date it is to be completed, or by the topic area that it is concerning. That way you can follow up on assignments by date, by person, or by subject.
Be sure that you inform others during the meeting that you will be following up on the assigned tasks. That way they will know that you will actually hold them accountable for what they were assigned. One last thing you can do to help follow-up is to use the next meeting’s agenda as a reminder. For example, if Sue Jones was to complete three tasks related to the IT system by the next meeting, you can put as an item ‘IT system – update from Sue Jones.’ That way you are providing one last reminder to the person that you expect to hear about their progress at the next meeting.
Fiske, Christine and Janet A. Clark. Negotiation Skills.
Johnson, Emjae. List of Basic Skills that Every Successful Sales Person Should Have.
MeetingWizard.org. Effective Meetings – Tips.
Mindtools.com. The 5 Whys. Quickly Getting to the Root of a Problem.
Mindtools.com. Communication Skills Articles, various
Mindtools.com. Conflict Resolution. Resolving Conflict Rationally and Effectively.
Mindtools.com. Running Effective Meetings.
MTD Training Academy. Basic Communication Skills
Neyman, John, Jr. 5 Powerful Tips to Persuasion.
Running Effective Meetings
© 2010 MTD Training & Ventus Publishing ApS